Wednesday, August 5, 2009

To Pity or To Encourage? - What a Question!

Lately I've been a voyeur of sorts. I've been on the outskirts of tragedy and ordinary discomforts, and of unnecessary freak outs for that matter. It has been an interesting time of gleaning. This wasn't a journey I sought out for myself, it sort of landed in my lap.

There have been people in my life who've had loved ones pass away and they've demonstrated such STRONG faith in God in the midst of their severest pain. They've shared their pain of the moment along with the confidence in God's ability to do and BE good in the midst of such loss. My time peeking into this experience has really caused me to reflect on myself and those I now see going through life's ups and downs.

This sight of such confidence and faith has made me weep uncontrollably at times and then left me feeling a desire to BE stronger. To not get so caught up in the little whining we all are prone to from time to time. It has made me unusually sensitive to the way we all tend to share a very MINOR inconvenience and present it in such a way that it appears our world is crashing down around us. It has become obvious to me, after watching all of these displays, that we all sometimes fall into the trap of wanting everyone around us to pity us for something that we should clearly deal with! It isn't THAT bad!

I've also witnessed another family go through the same road of grief and go into the 'why' phase of grief. (I'm sure the strong family will go through this phase too but I'm just sharing what God has shown me in all of this.) Hearing their heart cries of why and the feeling of desperately aching for that loved one is so easy to understand. To see their hearts literally ACHE makes my heart ACHE and I desire to hold them tightly and take their ache away.

I'm learning that some of our ordinary whining is another form of grief, some is warranted and some is not. Grieving the death of a friend or family member is a worthy journey in grief but grieving the loss of sleep or a phase of life with our kids/marriage (as a random example) causes a grief of sorts too. But it does often cause those who've been there before us to offer a common story to encourage you that it will get better. I've become very aware of watching those who share those minor hiccups of life continuously, they welcome (eagerly welcome) all of those who say 'You have such a hard life. Poor you.'. Sadly, the moment someone offers the teeniest bit of advice to encourage their friend they are silenced by the whining friend. The whining friend then tends to discontinue any further discussions on that topic. They don't say it but they are not allowing the person with the practical reality check to enter in the conversation. Well, they aren't WELCOMING them to talk because they are opposed to the reality check.

This whole observation has brought me MUCH understanding. I'm one who likes to encourage my friends when I see them crying out from a life experience. Sure, I know their world is not REALLY crumbling but I want to offer something to show them I care. There have been MANY times I've done such and I've pulled back my outstretched hand of friendship to find my hand was slapped. I've left these scenarios feeling "What did I do wrong? Did I offend them?". As a result, that relationship feels distant and I feel I must stifle myself around that person because I didn't know how I messed things up.

After watching these situations God has really shown me that there are seasons that people do NOT want any help or advice. They WANT pity they don't want an encouraging word or a cheery smile. They want to roll around in the 'poor me' world as long as they can get away with it. I'm ALL about a pity party! I can truly throw down in a pity party when they arise. I just think we are all better served if we advise our friends that encouragement needs to be left at the door for now due to an unplanned pity party. That way we aren't hurting one another without knowing.

The family who was not in the place to be encouraged through the death in their family - I respected their stance SO MUCH more because they said "I know so and so is in a better place but I just want them here now. I know that isn't fair or right but that's how I feel." Knowing they knew this made it so much easier to let them go 'there' with their cries because you knew where they stood. They were in that unreasonable phase and THEY knew that! (I of course would NEVER consider this experience of grief to be whining, by ANY means. So please do not mistake my use of whining and this example as being one in the same. This example was just one God used to magnify the examples in daily life. This family was authentic with where they were in the process, unlike many in ordinary places of pain.)

I've learned that there is a time and a place for an encouraging word now and I see that those friends who've basically slapped me for daring to encourage them felt insulted by my encouraging word. I'm learning through all of this to guard even an encouraging word, or let's say I will still give it but the instance I am slapped I will stop trying to comfort them for that moment, and realize that their unnecessary slap was really them just saying 'no thank you' to a friend lending an ear/encouraging word. It isn't personal - it is only where they are right now. That allows me to not get my feelings hurt and fall into the pit of wondering about the entire friendship. Now I can offer grace by being quiet knowing they are content, for now, in their misery (they have the Eeyore syndrome).

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Very well written - I love the way you explain the difference between those who truly want and need the compassionate encouragement and those who just want others to validate thier pity party.

Mis said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
MorningSong said...

I agree large and small struggles do warrant a friend listening. We agree!

It seems obvious that you do not understand my point. I am more than willing and able to sit with a friend and hear her share her heart and or listen to her 'whine' as you say. I think you seem to equate the 2.

I do not. Whining is not the same as unloading from a bad day. When a child whines it is an annoying constant irritating behavior that causes most who hear it to cringe in hopes that it will stop. A friend unloading to me is NOT whining. A pity party can be either whining (depending on the person's way of life) or unloading.

A friend who wants to unload will either
a) Share her heart in a genuine way that wants understanding or
b) Want to vent and be unreasonable in the venting or
c) Be on the verge of depression and want a life line.

Person b would do the world a service to say "I'm about to be ridiculous with my perspective on this, I just wanted you to know that before you try to encourage me."

I've met some person B's who've seemed frustrated when someone lends an encouraging word.

So it's not that I lack the willingness to be the sort of listener/adviser/ridiculous exaggerater that my friend needs. I'm saying the world would be a better place if more people were authentic enough to say what they want so they won't be offended by advise when they aren't interested and/or offend someone by snapping at them if someone tries to encourages them.

I guess if you've never had to be far away from those friends whom you can naturally flow with it is hard to imagine that this isn't easy. With a friend I've been friends with for years - this is effortless. Being in a place where my longest friendship is 3 years and really not that intensive due to the regular child interuptions - it isn't easy to read what everyone wants. With the people who know me and know my heart - they know that I am willing and able to laugh/cry/listen/grieve/or just sit - whatever is required. Without those security relationships near I'm realizing I've assumed a famliarity with new friends and found my response was less than desired.

MorningSong said...

I would find it tragic to know that I laughed when someone wanted to cry or cried when someone wanted to laugh. I guess having all my childhood relationships around to lean on easily would be the dream but that's not my story. Building friendships doesn't always come easy when people hide behind the standard "I'm fine" or the other extreme of exaggerating every little discomfort. The middle is ideal. Being on either extreme limits people from knowing the real you - it's a mask of sorts.

annieck said...

Sweet Melodye, I can see your point and empathize with you. I, like you, am one who likes to give advice. I mean, so many times, I have been through the same situation that my friends are struggling with and feel like I have a lot to offer to the situation. However, what I am learning, is that sometimes people don't want or need my advice. They just want to let all their frustrations out so they can feel better.
When you're (and by 'you', I mean anyone listening to the whining, not YOU specifically) the one listening to the whining, I guess it can get kind of irritating, especially if you don't consider the whining justified (due to its lack of importance in comparison to other "greater" tragedies going on). I think it's easy to want to throw some cold water on the person and say, "Wake up! Don't you know how good you have it?!?! Don't you realize what other people are going through? They would love to have your problems!"
However, on the flip side (because I have been on that side too), sometimes you just feel like the culmination of so many small things are going to break you. The late nights, the constant (and I mean constant) tornado disasters of a two year old in a home you just cleaned, the whining of a five year old, the lack of alone time or time with friends, the pressure of being a good wife and mom, etc. just builds and builds and you feel like you just need to "whine" about it a little, well, sometimes a LOT! I know I do anyway.

annieck said...

Looking at it and really thinking about it, I realize how blessed I am. I love my family. I would do anything for them. I feel guilty complaining about it at all, especially in light of the troubles others. I mean, people I know have sick children, children who may not live to see another day. I beat myself up about complaining about my little discomforts. This often causes me to bottle up all my frustrations and stresses (because I convince myself that no one wants to hear my whining), and I end up exploding or pulling back from everyone I love.
I have been so incredibly blessed, though, to have a couple of friends here that I feel I can be totally open with, without judgment. One, specifically, I know I can count on when i need to vent. On multiple occasions, she and I have sent each other emails complaining about anything and everything that is bothering us that week, everything that has caused us to break down and lose it. After we send the emails, we instantly feel better. We both know that we don't want any advice, we just want to have our little purge, our whine-fest, our pity party. Immediately, before we even hear from each other, we feel better. We have let it all out, every small insignificant thing that is driving us BONKERS, out.
When I sent her the first email, I beat myself up about it for DAYS thinking that I would lose a great friend because of my whining. I didn't, though, and can't tell you had good it made me feel to receive an email back a few weeks later filled with her purge. It made me feel that I wasn't alone! YEA! It made me feel that I could totally trust her, and that she wouldn't think I was crazy.
Like you, I am relatively new to this area. I left best friends, best friends who I feel like really know me and understand me, when we moved to this area. I, too, have dealt with difficult situations here because people I have been friends with didn't understand me or where I was coming from. Let me tell you, it has been a huge and eye-opening adjustment. I have often been left hurt, crying, upset, angry and confused as to what people expected from me and wondering how I could have been so misunderstood. What I've learned, though, is that everyone is different and needs to be handled differently. It doesn't always make life easy, but it constantly forces me to evaluate the words I use and where my words are coming from. Are they life-giving? Am I advising because I feel like I know it all or because I genuinely love the person and feel like God has led me to share a word with them. Often, my advice came from me and me alone.
Anyway, I am sure that you are truly sharing love and your heart. I pray that you will make those relationships that you so desire, true, open, loving relationships like you had back home. My heart aches that you feel it's hard to do here. I can totally empathize, though. It's tough. Wouldn't life be so much easier if people just 'got' us?! Ha!
I love you, Melodye, and think the world of you!

MorningSong said...

Oh Annie! THANK you! You do get it! :) I mean just that! If you need to vent it is WONDERFUL to KNOW you can be loopy nuts with your complaining and KNOW you are not being misunderstood because you have the safe place to do that. Some, I'm guessing, do not have that OR they are just so heavy burdened that all they do is whine about every moment in their life. Both scenarios need to get the icky feelings out but I'm learning to just listen to the perpetual whiners now and say 'Ahuh... ahuh" instead of trying to encourage them. We all need to just get that stuff out but I'm learning to guard myself better in those situations and I do believe being in a totally new place without the comforts of tried and true friendships caused me to have to see how I was quick to encourage (as I would with my friends) and left feeling I somehow hurt the one with the bad day. I now can clearly see that it is discouraging to not get that out - even if (from my perspective) I would save those moments for someone I knew I could lean on vs. everyone I know. I am so thankful for your words - they may clear up what I'm finding hard to say! I love you and am forever grateful that you've allowed me to start today off feeling understood! YIPPPEEEE!

annieck said...

Thanks, Melodye! I think you're awesome and hope you have a fantastic day, my friend!!! Keep on keeping on. You can share your encouragement with me any day! :)

MorningSong said...

Just one more clarification. The families I mentioned going through grief - BOTH hurt and BOTH will go through the full blown grief process. It really isn't about them.

The point is - in our ordinary disappointments we either let our emotions lead us into a whirlwind of messes or we look to God to lead us in His strength. The example of grieving has no place except God gave me a mental picture with these families. No family is grieving better than the other. That is just the window that brought understanding.